InkiconMake your set

Comparisons

The best tools for making a custom icon set in 2026

We built Inkicon, so of course it's at the top of this list. We still want you to end up with the right icons. Sometimes that means a free set, sometimes Recraft, and sometimes a designer. Here's how we'd pick.

Details of other products were checked in November 2026. Things change quickly in this space, so check their sites before you buy anything.

Why we built another icon tool

Inkicon started with a reading app that needed calligraphic icons: ink strokes that swell and taper. No stock pack had anything close. We spent a lot of rounds prompting image models, and most of the results were either inconsistent or blurred into nothing at 16 px. The breakthrough was boring. We took a sheet that was nearly right and asked for one short change. Then we wrote a tracer to turn the approved drawing into real vectors.

That experience shaped this list. We only care about one job here: the 20 to 100 small icons inside an app or website, in a style that's yours. A tool that's brilliant at illustrations but leaves you with twelve PNGs in slightly different weights hasn't done that job.

Good forYou getCost
1. InkiconA full custom set in your styleSVG, sprite, React components, optional animation5 free drawings, then pay once per pack
2. RecraftIcons as part of wider design workVector and image downloadsRecraft's own plans
3. Free setsA clean, neutral look at no costSVG plus framework packagesFree
4. Image generatorsExploring a moodPNG imagesTheir own plans
5. IconifyAIYour app-store iconLarge app icon imagesSee their site
6. A designerA flagship brand systemWhatever you agreeA fee, and a few weeks

1. Inkicon

You pick one of six house styles, or give it a reference image (your logo works well) and a sentence or two about the feel you want. It draws the whole set on one sheet, so the icons grow up together instead of being made one at a time and hoping they match. Each one is then traced to SVG on a 24×24 grid.

Before you see anything, the set gets checked. Icons too thin or muddy to read at 16 px are flagged. So are icons that wander off the family's line weight, and any two that came out looking the same. It won't replace your eye, and you should still look at every icon, but it catches the faults we kept missing by hand.

The download is meant for code: SVGs in currentColor, a sprite, a README and typed React components. There's an optional animated pack, which falls back to static icons for people who've turned motion off. If you work with a coding agent, it can ask for a set through our MCP server. When you need a new icon in six months, it's drawn from your original sheet, so it still belongs.

Honestly, if Lucide already has every icon you need and you like how it looks, use Lucide. Inkicon earns its place when you want a look of your own, or when you need icons nobody else has drawn. You can try 5 drawings free, then pay once for each finished pack (see pricing).

Example: the calligraphic house set, traced to SVG and shown at 16, 24 and 48 px.
add
calendar
delete
download
edit
heart
home
notifications
search
settings
share
user

Start from this style →

2. Recraft

Recraft is a general AI design tool. It does illustrations, mock-ups and brand imagery, and it does icons too, in sets of up to six per generation. You can steer it with presets or an uploaded brand style. If your icons are one item on a longer design to-do list, having everything in one tool is a real advantage, especially if your team already pays for it.

A 60-icon interface set takes a lot of six-icon generations, though, and keeping them consistent is up to you. Small-size checks aren't something Recraft lists. Our full Inkicon vs Recraft comparison.

3. Lucide, Heroicons and the other free sets

These are genuinely great. Lucide, Heroicons, Phosphor, Tabler and Material Symbols are well drawn, well maintained and free, and most come with React or Vue packages. Plenty of good products ship with nothing else.

The catch shows up later. Your app looks like a lot of other apps. Then one day you need an icon the set doesn't have, borrow it from a second pack, and it sits there slightly too heavy. If that hasn't happened to you yet, stick with free. When a free set is enough · Lucide alternatives.

4. General image generators

The image models built into chat assistants are fun for finding a direction. We used them a lot at the start. But they give you PNGs, every prompt is drawn on its own, and nothing checks how an icon reads at the size it'll actually be used. Turning a folder of those images into a consistent SVG set is a project in itself.

One tip from our own trial and error: once you have an image that's close, a short, focused edit usually beats rewriting the whole prompt. More on that here.

5. IconifyAI

This one solves a different problem. IconifyAI is described as an app icon generator. It makes the single big image people see on their home screen or in a store, not the small icons inside your app. Most products need both, so it isn't really either/or. Inkicon vs IconifyAI.

6. Hiring an icon designer

A good icon designer will beat every tool on this page. If icons are central to a big brand, or you need several weights, pixel-hinted sizes and someone to look after the set for years, hire one. It'll cost a proper fee and take weeks, and it's often worth it.

A middle route works well too. Find the direction in Inkicon, then hand the editable SVGs to a designer to finish. Inkicon vs hiring a designer.

So which one?

If you want your own consistent icon set as SVG and you want it this week, we'd say Inkicon. If a neutral look is fine, save your money and use a free set. If icons are a small part of a bigger design job, look at Recraft. For the app-store icon, use IconifyAI. For a flagship brand, hire a designer.

Not sure your current icons hold up? Drop them into our free SVG icon checker and see how they look at 16 and 24 px.

Try Inkicon free →